With Thanks to :
03 MARCH 2013
You Are Not Family
I have often been
asked if I miss being in the air force. This is is a rather popular question,
and one even I have foolishly asked when mingling with some senior officers on
the brink of retirement. The universal answer was always, yes,
and when followed with what it was they missed the answer was always comradeship.
I do not miss the
comradeship. I have discovered that come any street, I have the ability to make
friends. And friends will do what friends do, in service or out in civvy
street. That's an entire different argument there.
The point is, it
isn't the comradeship that I miss.
It's the
involvement.
Everyone thinks
they have heard all there is to hear about Lahad Datu. And God be my witness, I
wish I were right there to do something about it. If they called me now, I
would be there yesterday bearing arms.
I have really had
it with the rubbish that has been spewed in the alternative media, where even facebook
has not been spared.
How easy it is to
condemn and criticise the working man, whether soldier or policeman on the
ground, over your dissatisfactions with the establishment. How simplistic it is
to draft the unfounded analogous parallel to an intruder into your home, when
you haven't accounted for turning on the lights and finding your cousin staring
back at your baseball bat at the ready to bludgeon his head. How horribly
obscene it is to make all this a racial episode, forgetting that all races
have died in service to King and country, as easily overlooked that it was not
just one race that took up the armed communist struggle in our
rainforests. Worst of all, it is an outrage that anyone, individual and entity
alike, should look so poorly upon the lives that were taken in the
shootout at Lahad Datu by milking it for illicit political mileage.
The kind of
remarks that have been passed in the alternative media has made me feel that a
great many of us perhaps deserve less than what we claim we are entitled to in
a transparent and graft-free government.
From the comfort
of your air conditioned homes and plush offices, you would pose as the
intellectual authority on how the police are supposed to handle this quagmire
of a crisis. Your gleaning of a few lurid misadventures when you have
brushed with them from the wrong side of the law does not equate to an
intimate knowledge of their modus operandi.
What recent
events have unearthed is a hoarde of the ugliest Malaysian attitudes I have had
the displeasure to read. If this is any shade of colour on the civic
consciousness litmus, the singular conclusion must be that we are not ready for
public opinion to be a driving force for government policy.
When do you think
that you were made entitled to disclosure of military manouvres? When you
survived Outward Bound School?
Everything in the
military runs on a security classification. Even the "UNCLASSED"
documents are for internal reading only. While you are so reluctant to serve,
and discourage anyone who shows an interest in becoming a soldier, you think
you can fathom the details of who should handle what in such an intricate
crisis?
There are some
professions you have no right to pass judgement on unless you have given your
blood into them, soldiering being high on that heirarchy. You're not of the
fraternity, so forever hold your piece! You are not family!!
Those who slurred
at the armed forces as being good only for butt-wriggling exercises have
exposed their intelligence for what it is: the myopic inability to discern
between a serving soldier bound by discipline, and a retired veteran's group
which isn't. Do you know how stupid you sound to those of us from the
profession of arms??
Those who charge
that our armed forces are low on training and experience should conduct better
research instead of infusing beer and conspiracy novels as sources of military
intelligence.
You cannot
legitimise military action in a civil area unless it has been declared as no
man's land and hostilities have been announced. The Malaysian Armed Forces is a
highly trained organisation sought after by the UN from our days in conflicts
in Congo, Cambodia, Bosnia, the Middle East and the volatile Eritrea. We have
officers who have single handedly slaughtered a truckload of Mogadishu warlords
on the verge of slaying women and children; we have officers who managed
to apply escape and evasion tactics after abduction and torture at the
hands of Sierra Leone bandits, veterans of the communist insurgency, and a
collective of several decades of service in humanitarian aid and disaster
relief areas. They know the legal complications of using military options as a
first resort, the implications of having to be bound by the Laws Of Armed
Conflict and the Geneva Convention. Indeed, those very laws were manipulated
and violated in order to draw our secuirty forces into the killing zone when
the intruders waved the white flag as a prelude to gunning our
boys down. You just cannot deal summarily with this viscous situation.
I do not envy the
position of our governing politicans now because it is such a delicate
situation yet they know they are damned if they do and damned if they don't.
While they may have bungled during times of civil dissent, these shades of
incompetence do not validate the widespread claims by
Joe Public that Joe Public has a better grasp on the burden of
responsibility replete with the tactical and strategic weildings to make this
work and that therefore the various ministers attempting to unravel this mess
should resign. Joe, you are indeed laughable because in your self-inflicted
significance and stupor you intend to hold the backdoor open for someone
holding public office to run off before the assembly of the full orchestra can
take place. Do this only if you can close the door and occupy the emptied seat.
The Royal
Malaysian Police have given their lives to guard your homes in the Lahad Datu
stand-off.
As the episode
has yet to conclude, it is not known yet how many more lives will be lost.
But as policemen
and soldiers get their orders to move into the area, those orders are obeyed in
the face of death. They have no choice. They have always known this and
they march into battle when their time arrives.
Do not even begin
to justify the cost of their lives with the taxes you pay or the job they have
undertaken. Nothing you pare out of your ill-gotten gains can pay off the
widows and orphans trailing in the wake of those who have done what you can
choose not to do. No amount of intellectualisation will ever raise you to the
level of sacredity they attain for knowingly going, without a backward glance,
especially on behalf of those who scoff at them.
Therefore, since
you have neither the inclination to take up a gun and work with others by placing
your life in their hands and defending their lives with yours, nor the spirit
to run for office and face being blamed by your own breed, leave those who have
the dirty work to do what dirty work there is.
As far as I can
see, you have begun by your crescendo of Crucify them!! Crucify them!! only to
be followed by Hossana!! Hossana!! when your barking has been choked in your
throat when met with the blood of those whom you condemn.
I tell you
verily, this makes you nothing more than a brood of vipers.
Bagaimana nak jawap ni?
ReplyDeleteNobody is criticising the ATM.
We are angry our ATM are being put at unnecessary risk because of the prevailing stupidity of the PM and HM. Habis cerita. Bila GE nanti kita ABU!
Pak, America is trillions in debt fighting other peoples wars. Can someone tabulate how much it is costing the Gomen to finance this "war" on the sulu insurgents?
ReplyDeleteI tak faham what this guy is screaming about. So does it mean that we can continue to have a useless government who does not care two hoots of Sabah' borders, yes and to go on issuing ICs to these philipino migrants just becos it is all in the name of Muslim brotherhood, and that they are welcomed to stay in Lahad Datu.. blah2? So we can't criticize the manner in which the episode is being handled and that whatever silly decisions the present ruling government makes, we have to go along? And then we are family? Crap!
ReplyDeleteThank you for taking the time to write your thoughts. A well written piece. It is healthy to have differing views. It helps all readers to expand their minds and view issues and situation from another perspective; liken to being in the other person's shoes. I believe that many who has posted a comment or write an article on the Lahad Datu debacle were expressing their disgruntlement of a corrupt government which focuses on enriching themselves and not to take care of the rakyat. We are family, we are all Malaysians. I agree with the writer that if we are not in the family of the armed forces, we are not in the know to criticize the professionalism nor their level of training. I admit that in my simplistic thinking as a mere rakyat, I do wonder why the authority did not send the army but the police. I felt, merely expressing my feelings that the authority is putting our police at unnecessary risk and caused the loss of precious lives. Since the author highlighted that this is civilized zone and not an area to send the army, my question would be: "Wouldn't it become a warzone when all civilians have been evacuated? I also read that our intelligence received news of the invasion over a month earlier. Why didn't the authority make preparation to protect our shore, our land and our people? It is ridiculous to me that our Home Minister still classify them as not invaders when they arrived fully armed. Would you classify them as "tourists"? It may be good to "talk" first and persuade them to leave, but did our authorities post our arm forces to make sure the invaders were guarded until they leave? I may not know everything and I am no soldier but I am Malaysian. I love the country, the people and I care. I may not know the system, the method nor how to fight but I have commonsense and think to QUESTION. As Malaysians, we have the right to question constructively so that we have progress and growth for the good of all citizens. When the author accused others of not joining the arm forces, has he ever given deeper thoughts as to the reason why there were more non-malays in the arm forces before 1980's and the number declined after 80's. I trust that you have the intellect to figure out yourself. I respect your views and I agree with you on the bravery and the sacrifice made by those who answered the call of duty; they don't turn nor glance back. They march forward even knowing that death awaits them. I cried learning of the bloodshed. I pray for the surviving families and believe that Allah, God Almighty, the Creator protect and comfort them. I would encourage all to stop pointing fingers nor vent our anger over our loss. Sabah is in crisis. Lets unite. Even Lim Kit Siang has called and pledged solidarity with the BN government to resolve this crisis. I heard his speech issued in public (Johor) on Monday night. The ordinary citizen should at least pray daily for our armed forces if they cannot fight along side.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDear Jen Leong
ReplyDeleteSince you have been courteous, please allow me to address you here over your question on the participation of non-Malays in the armed forces, and from the perspective of an officer, as the other ranks' path is not for me to comment on.
The dwindling numbers are a function of many factors. Chief amongst them is that the war was winding down. We managed to make this war so unprofitable for the CPM that they agreed to lay down their armed struggle in 1989. This was a world's first.
Next, it also depends on how you see yourself as a non-Malay in the armed forces. If you look forward to a career, or a business venture, sometimes you may succeed with cunning and acumen. Often times not, for you are piited against the numerical and sectarian odds. Promotions are lost, sidelining is common. That does not encourage numbers. Then you will find that such "failed businessmen" will advertise against anyone else taking a chance.
You also have those who sign up to gain a trade. They serve in logistics, in engineering, as legal directorate officers, seamen, pilots, fire specialists, radar techs, whatnot. Those who are lucky to be signed up as short service commission officers leave at term's end and live fruitful lives in the quiet of post-service years.
Then there are those of us who joined up just to serve. The promotions didn't matter as we knew this is government service. We just wanted to be an influence for things to work correctly. We looked way beyond personal pain and rising through the ranks as an index of self-worth, and gave till there was none left, and then some. I hate cliches, but this is where you actually get to be all that you can be.
I had the privilege of serving under various trades, as a fire officer, air trafficker and as a pilot as I sought to pursue what I felt I was able to do but was dropped off over the way things were according to their times.
I was privileged in that from the time of commissioning I was taken seriously notwithstanding my rank, and had no problems with providing input towards operational decisions to my generals, often without counter argument. I will not say too much about this, suffice that there are current practices and hardware that are results of my input, and I am amongst many who have contributed this way. I would be summoned from meetings by my four-stars for matters such as these. And yet, at the lower echelons I was perceived as a threat. I too have faced the very matters that discourage non-Malays from signing up. But to yield is to be defeatist. To quit before you are ready is to allow the enemy within his undeserved victory.
I can say without remorse that those who leave should leave happily. Baggage weighs you down. And becomes the birthplace for misplaced vitriol. This is not an answer that will satisfy the masses. It was my own answer as I gave what I had to King and country no matter what horrors I witnessed my leaders commit, no matter what insult the public voiced.
Forgive my geriatric meanderings.
Well, you Anonymous(es), in the first instance I write on my own blog for my own pleasure and not yours. I seek no consensus nor affirmation. LOL!! Nobody read my blog for 5 years and nobody gave a damn. Kinda nice really :)
ReplyDeleteOne of the failings of the internet age is that instead of liberating fertile opinion, it has bred opinionism. The anonymity and impunity of the net allows you to criticise all and sundry, over matters that are not under your control. Sometimes this is great. Other times it is brainless. I admit it serves as self therapy but for most it remains as self indulgent hand relief. And decisions on territorial sovereignty is a field not open to Joe and Jane Public. Period.
Claimed proprietorship of common sense may be made on the common street, but not along the private chambers where difficult decisions are made. Such decisions are not on your shoulder and yelp as you may here, you have no influence on the outcome whether for victory or for defeat.
But there are those who have no choice but to obey. They bear a burden beyond what you can fathom and they do it even if they feel the way you do about the government. That is where boys are separated from men. It is bad enough that both sides of the political hagglers will be exploiting this episode for their own political buoyancy and survival, without those on the sidelines who have no intent in becoming part of the solution volunteering unwarranted comment and contributing to the problem. What makes it worse, especially for armchair generals and politicans alike, is that no matter what we see in the government, they cannot be denied looking good at how their servants have handled the situation on the ground. Much to your chagrin perhaps, but see what yapping does??
Those who are legally trained understand the need for restraint on public comment over a trial still under proceedings. I do not plead that you accord the same respect for a very trying time for all Malaysians. That is if you believe that in these times there is something bigger at hand than your own sentiments, and that is to stand together with your elected leaders for whatever outcome this may bring; that is if you actually believe in this country at all. You can stand with your captain and try to keep the ship afloat, or you can jump off like a hoarde of rats. Your choices reflect your allegiences.
I have said my piece. I do not seek to convert the inconvertible who insist on so much while contributing little.
In the end when all falls to dust in is those whom you condemn who will have to watch your sorry asses.
Just sayin'.